Are Ellipticals Better Than Treadmills? Let’s Compare And Contrast
Category: Fitness Machine & Workout Tips
So the burning question always is: Are Ellipticals Better Than Treadmills? This article helps to shed some light on each as well as outline the benefits each of these fitness machines brings to the table as well as where it falls short.
The elliptical machine is often better known as the cross trainer, and you’ll usually find someone milling around one of these two, waiting for the other person to finish.
But, despite them both having a high level of popularity, which one is actually better? Or, are they both great, but for different purposes?
Both are ideal cardiovascular workout options, but let’s pit one against the other and determine the winner.
Elliptical Machine: Pros and Cons
An elliptical machine, or cross trainer, is designed to give both your legs and your arms a workout, while also strengthening your core.
Elliptical Machine Benefits:
Low impact on the joints
Your feet are always on the foot pedals and the pneumatic or fly-wheel mechanism means that the movement is controlled and swift, not ‘clunky.’ This helps to protect your joints in particular.
An easy, natural way to exercise
The motion you will adopt when using the machine is quite natural in its feel, and it moves naturally, i.e. your body won’t be put under stress by moving in a way it isn’t used to.
You are working out your upper and lower body
By using the arm section of the machine as well, are you working out not only your lower body, but also your upper body too, specifically the arms. Your core is also strengthened in the process.
Several settings available
You can change the incline, resistance, and speed quite easily on a cross trainer, and combine it with intervals to enhance your workout.
Elliptical Machine Drawbacks:
Your feet may hurt or become numb
The downside of your feet never leaving the pedals is that they might start to hurt quite quickly, because of the lack of movement. You might also experience numbness, which can be uncomfortable.
A lack of impact isn’t always a positive thing
We mentioned that an elliptical trainer gives you zero impact, but in order to keep your bones to their optimum strength, you do need a little impact (albeit controlled).
You might struggle with balance at first
The feel of using an elliptical machine is quite natural, but because you’re off the ground, you might struggle with balance on the first try. You might also notice that your legs burn quite a lot – this will get easier, so don’t give up!
Treadmill: The Pros And Cons
A treadmill allows you to run or walk. You can either hold onto the arm rests, or you can move your arms naturally.
You can tailor your workout
You can make your workout as high or low impact as you want, by choosing the speed at which you walk or run. This makes a treadmill ideal for practically everyone.
A range of setting available
You can increase or decrease your speed as you see fit throughout your workout, and you can also incline the belt for a harder challenge.
Ideal for runners in particular
If you’re a running or walking fan, and you find it hard to get outside, e.g. you live somewhere busy or the weather is bad, the treadmill is an ideal option.
A simple machine to learn
There aren’t a huge amount of gadgets on a treadmill, so it is easy to get the hang of for beginners.
An expensive machine
Treadmills are certainly more expensive than elliptical machines if you want to set up a home gym. In addition, running isn’t usually very easy on a home treadmill, because the ground beneath has to be extremely stable.
A higher risk of falls or injury
It can be difficult to get used to the movement of the belt at first, and it can also be very easy to become distracted by something, causing you to trip and fall. This increases the risk of injury.
Can be quite boring
Simply walking or running and not doing anything else can be a boring way to exercise.
Are Ellipticals Better Than Treadmills? Which One is The Winner?
As you can see from our comparison of elliptical vs treadmill, both elliptical machines and treadmills have a range of pros and cons in either direction. So Are Ellipticals Better Than Treadmills? It really does come down to personal choice, and what you want to achieve from your workout.
For an overall body workout, the elliptical machine wins marginally, but treadmills are still an extremely popular and quality way to work out.
Perhaps the best answer is that both are suitable in their own ways, and you should use both for a high quality workout routine.
Related posts & articles that may be of interest to you:
Moving can be a pain, especially when you have heavy exercise machinery that needs to be taken from one place to another. Even relocating your equipment from your top floor to the bottom one can lead to damaging…
Are you looking for a treadmill for home use? This treadmill buying guide is will give you some handy tips in choosing the best treadmill to suit both your budgetary and exercise goals. You might be one of those…
Elliptical machine doesn’t specifically target the stomach and abdominal muscles, burning calories generally reduces the waistline to some degree anyway
Sometimes going to the gym can feel embarrassing because the idea of people watching you while you exercise is mortifying. You want to be dedicated to being healthier but simply can’t get yourself through the…
Ellipticals have a variety of benefits, such as: Causing less impact on your joints Providing a full body workout Being a suitable form of exercise for people who are ill, elderly or pregnant Improving your cardiovascular system On…
How Long Should You Run On An Elliptical To Lose Weight Effectively? One of the most frequent questions I have been asked has been, “how long should you run on an elliptical to lose weight?”. After some thinking I figured I could not keep on ignoring this question and have been compelled to write an…
Before you decide on the best elliptical to buy, there are some general and personal considerations you should keep in mind. This will help you check all the right boxes and make sure you end up…
If you are using an elliptical to workout and lose weight, am sure you are asking yourself: how accurate are elliptical calorie counters? Sometimes people can get preoccupied with how many calories their ellipticals say they’re burning. Burning calories means weight loss,…
Speed training is an important part of any sport and it can also be beneficial to anyone who is trying to improve their overall fitness. Speed training not only helps you to run faster, but can help you improve the…
Are you optimizing your daily schedule to its fullest potential? If you are someone who works out on a daily basis, you probably understand the importance of having a set schedule daily workout routine. However, in today’s…
Are you tired of not seeing results from your current weekly exercise plan? Whether you are trying to lose or gain weight, your workout routine demands a dose of variety. In today’s society, it is so…
Most fitness experts will tell you that bodyweight ab workout exercises by themselves are not likely to give you those washboard abs you are seeking. Neither will they help you burn that excess body fat or improve your overall health. If…
Are you considering buying an under desk bike or for a home gym or exercising while at the office? If so, you may want to read this article before you proceed and spend your hard earned money. Getting your…
So you have decided to finally get off the couch and get back into your fitness routine and back on track for get your weight loss goals but are wondering what the best home exercise equipment for weight loss…
So you are you are interested in finding, picking and buying an indoor cycling bike. With the overwhelming types and choices out there where do you start? How do you choose not only best exercise bike…
Upper body workout and strength is extremely important since your upper body controls many of your daily activities including, reaching, pulling, pushing and lifting. In addition, having a strong upper body helps to improve your overall flexibility, mobility…
For years fitness watches were to be used by men and fitness watches for women were practically unheard of – forcing women who wanted a watch to track their fitness to wear fitness watches designed and made for…
There are two basic types of exercise bikes, the upright bike and the stationary recumbent bike and many people simply don’t know which bike is right for them. In this article “Upright vs Stationary Recumbent Bike: Which One Is Right…
It does not matter whether you live in a rural area, a small town or a large city, you can enjoy the many health and other benefits of jogging as an exercise. You can jog as a part of…
If you are having difficulty deciding which one is better for you then this article on treadmill vs bike will give the information you need to decide which one of these two pieces of exercise equipment will best meet your needs…
How would you track your daily calories intake and how many calories you burned while exercising? It all comes down to picking the right and best fitness activity tracker. So this article will help and provide you with best…
Elliptical machines and treadmills have a range of pros and cons. It really does come down to personal choice, and what you want to achieve.
Everybody is different and finding the right can often be a chore. Some machinery doesn’t accommodate people with sensitive joints while others can be too expensive to maintain. That’s why ellipticals are here to stay. They can be useful tools…
Leave your vote
Interested in more options in this category? Check out our extended product listing below:
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-E905 Elliptical Machine Cross Trainer with 8 Level Resistance and Digital Monitor
$142.45 in stock
2 used from $83.38
Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical Trainer Machine w/Device Holder, LCD Monitor, 265 LB Max Weight and Pulse Monitoring - Circuit Zone, Black (SF-E3862)
Body Power 2-in-1 Elliptical Stepper Trainer with Curve-Crank Technology
$319.99 in stock
2 used from $257.53
ATIVAFIT Under Desk Elliptical Bike, Pedal Exerciser, Mini Elliptical Machine with Non-Slip Pedal, Display Monitor and Adjustable Resistance, Quiet & Compact Home Office Trainer Fitness Peddler
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-E902 Air Walk Trainer Elliptical Machine Glider w/ LCD Monitor, 220 LB Max Weight and 45 Inch Stride, Black/Gray
$97.30 in stock
5 used from $89.52
Marcy Magnetic Elliptical Trainer Cardio Workout Machine with Transport Wheels NS-40501E
1 used from $210.00
Sunny Health & Fitness Portable Stand Up Elliptical - SF-E3908, Gray
$114.56 in stock
2 used from $102.10
Body Power 3-in-1 Exercise Machine, Trio Trainer, Elliptical and Upright/Recumbent Bike BRT5088 gray, silver, red
$218.89 in stock
1 used from $198.37
Body Rider Elliptical Trainer and Exercise Bike with Seat and Easy Computer / Dual Trainer 2 in 1 Cardio Home Office Fitness Workout Machine BRD2000
Mini Exercise Bike, AGM Digital Under Desk Bike Foot Cycle Arm & Leg Peddler Machine with LCD Screen Displays(Black)
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5639 Full Motion Rowing Machine Rower w/ 350 lb Weight Capacity and LCD Monitor
$129.00 in stock
6 used from $118.68
Body Power 3-in-1 Exercise Machine, Trio Trainer, Elliptical and Upright/Recumbent Bike BRT5118
$255.94 in stock
2 used from $186.36
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-E3607 Magnetic Elliptical Bike Elliptical Machine w/ Device Holder, LCD Monitor and Heart Rate Monitoring, grey
Sunny Health & Fitness Squat Assist Row-N-Ride Trainer for Glutes Workout with Training Video
$109.99 in stock
9 used from $90.12
NICEDAY Elliptical Machine, Cross Trainer with Hyper-Quiet Magnetic Driving System, 16 Resistance Levels, 400LB Weight Limit
$599.00 in stock
Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical Trainer Machine w/Device Holder, Programmable Monitor and Heart Rate Monitoring, 330 LB Max Weight - SF-E3912
$387.76 in stock
1 used from $141.66
Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Standing Elliptical with Handlebars - SF-E3988, Grey
3 used from $74.72
LifePro Under Desk Elliptical Trainer for Home & Office - Calf Leg Foot Pedal Exerciser - Seated Compact Elliptical Bike Machine - Core Fitness Low Impact Exercise Equipment w/Adjustable Resistance
Stamina InMotion Compact Strider, Black, (L x W x H):24.00 x 18.00 x 12.00 IN
$129.00 in stock
3 used from $110.48
Marcy Foldable Exercise Bike with Adjustable Resistance for Cardio Workout and Strength Training NS-652
4 used from $94.71
Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical Trainer Machine w/ Tablet Holder, LCD Monitor, 265 Max Weight and Pulse Monitor - Stride Zone - SF-E3865,Black
$675.27 in stock
1 used from $388.22
Sunny Health & Fitness Premium Cardio Climber Stepping Elliptical Machine - SF-E3919, Black
$387.76 in stock
Vaunn Medical Folding Pedal Exerciser with Electronic Display for Legs and Arms Workout (Fully Assembled Exercise Peddler, no Tools Required)
$49.99 in stock